Heat pump or electric for a Wantirna home?
When an old electric cylinder needs replacing, most Wantirna households have a choice to make. Here is how the two options compare.
- Licensed and insured
- Local to Wantirna 3152
- Quote agreed first
- After-hours call-outs
How they differ
An electric storage system heats water with an element, much like a kettle, and stores it in an insulated tank. A heat pump draws heat from the air with a refrigeration cycle and transfers it to the water. It does the same job with a fraction of the electricity.
Running cost
A heat pump uses much less electricity than an electric storage system to heat the same water, so its running cost is significantly lower. For a family that uses a lot of hot water, the difference adds up quickly. An electric unit on an off-peak tariff costs less to run than one on a general tariff, but is still more expensive than a heat pump.
Upfront cost
Electric storage units cost less to buy and install. Heat pumps cost more upfront, though government programs can reduce that, depending on the product and your circumstances. Over the life of the unit, many households find the heat pump works out cheaper overall.
Placement
An electric cylinder can go almost anywhere: laundry, cupboard, garage or outside. An integrated heat pump needs good airflow and usually sits outside, often on the same pad as an old outdoor cylinder. In a tight laundry, a split heat pump can keep the tank indoors with the compressor outside.
Noise
Electric cylinders are silent. Heat pumps make a low hum while running, similar to an air conditioner's outdoor unit. Placing the unit away from bedrooms and setting it to run during the day avoids most issues, including with neighbours in Wantirna's closer-set units and townhouses.
Rooftop solar
If you have solar panels, a heat pump set to run in the middle of the day can heat your water largely from your own generation. An electric cylinder can also run on a timer during the day, but uses more of that solar power to do the same job.
Which suits you?
- Heat pump: you plan to stay in the home for a few years, use a fair amount of hot water, have somewhere outside with airflow, and want lower running costs.
- Electric storage: you want the lowest upfront cost, need a quick like-for-like swap, or the unit has to stay in an enclosed space.
Get advice
We can look at your home, your household and where the unit would go, and recommend what makes sense. See heat pump hot water, hot water replacement or ring 03 9069 5874.
Tell us what needs fixing
Tell us about the job and a licensed Wantirna plumber will ring you back. If water is flooding or a sewer is overflowing, do not wait for a reply: call 03 9069 5874 now.
Every job is priced on what we find on the day, so there is no price list here. You will always know the cost before we start.
More guides
Need a plumber in Wantirna?
A licensed local plumber picks up, and the cost is settled before any tools come out.